When municipalities and public authorities seek to take back operations from private providers, unexpected problems often arise. New research shows that long-standing relationships and informal agreements can make it difficult to end collaborations, even when contracts are not being followed.

An increasing number of public-sector organisations are discussing whether services should be run in-house or by private providers. However, switching between private and public provision is often more complicated than theories of competitive markets suggest.
Studies of cases from different parts of Sweden show that public and private actors often become mutually dependent on one another over time. This can make it difficult to terminate contracts or change the mode of provision when conditions change.
“Our results show that there is a clear gap between how public procurement is intended to function and how it functions in practice,” says Magnus Jansson, researcher at RISE and Docent in Social Psychology at the University of Skövde.
Informal agreements keep operations running
The research also shows that so-called tacit contracts often develop between the parties. These consist of informal agreements that allow operations to continue functioning despite problems or shortcomings in the collaboration.
“In practice, stability is sometimes prioritised over strict control. This may be necessary to avoid disruptions in essential public services, but it also means that market rules do not always function as intended,” says Magnus Jansson.
Cooperation can increase as contracts near their end
Another finding is that cooperation often intensifies as a contract approaches its end. During the transition, both parties seek to ensure that operations continue without interruption, which can sometimes push conflicts and problems into the background.
“Decisions to outsource services or bring them back in-house need to take account of the unexpected. It is not only about economics, but also about relationships and dependencies that develop over time,” says Magnus Jansson.
An important conclusion is that municipalities and other public organisations need to plan better for situations where contracts are terminated early or where operations need to be rapidly brought back in-house.
